How Do You Choose the Right Agent — and Recover When a Deal Falls Through?
Gary and Maria Moss talked to five different agents before selling their Renton home — including neighbors who'd used other agents, and a relative's recommendation. None of them felt right until they spoke with Melissa. Five days after listing, they had a full-price offer with multiple bids on the table.
The Property
A 2-bedroom Barbee Mill home near Lake Washington, with a main-level office that functions as a third bedroom, resort-style outdoor living space, and clubhouse and dock access — built recently, 2,100 square feet.
The Sellers' Goal
Confidence. Before anything else, Gary and Maria wanted an honest read on what their home would actually sell for — not the optimistic number other agents had been offering to win the listing.
The Challenge
Other agents they'd interviewed had lowballed their expectations on price. Trusting the right number — and the right person to deliver it — mattered more than moving fast.
Preparation
The home was prepared and listed with a marketing plan built around what Barbee Mill buyers actually respond to — the lake proximity, the clubhouse access, the resort-style outdoor living space.
Marketing
Professional presentation of the home's standout features — the covered patio, fireplace, and motorized shades — positioned it against a buyer pool that shops Lake Washington-adjacent communities specifically.
Pricing
Priced to match what the market would actually support, rather than the inflated numbers other agents had floated to win the listing.
Negotiation
Multiple offers came in within five days of listing. The accepted offer matched the full list price.
The Result
Listed at $1,450,000. Sold at $1,450,000 — full list price, five days on market, multiple offers.
What Made the Difference
Gary and Maria chose Melissa specifically because she gave them a number they could trust when other agents were telling them what they wanted to hear. That honesty is what the fast, full-price result was actually built on.
Why Renton/Kennydale Expertise Matters
Barbee Mill is a small, amenity-specific community — knowing exactly which features matter to buyers there, and pricing accurately for that micro-market rather than Renton broadly, is what separates a fast sale from a sitting listing.
Client Testimonial
"Melissa was amazing from start to finish through all the stress of selling our home. We picked her out of five different agents we spoke to about selling our home... She was extremely responsive, had great recommendations on how to best sell our home, and agreed with us on the price of our home when other agents seemed to lowball us. She sold our home in five days with multiple offers!" — Maria Moss
Frequently Asked Questions
-
A: Ask for their comps and reasoning, not just a number — and be wary of the highest quote if it isn't backed by data.
-
A: A well-priced, well-marketed home in this community can generate multiple offers within a week.